As an Amazon Associate, AYTXX earns from qualifying purchases.
Introduction
If you’re shopping for an electric smoker, this guide compares four well-known models so you can pick a unit that fits your backyard and skill level. Below you’ll find at-a-glance picks, product features taken from manufacturer listings, practical pros and cons, a buyer’s guide that explains what to look for (capacity, controls, moisture and smoke control, vertical vs. horizontal), plus recommendations by buyer type.
Quick comparison — at-a-glance picks and who each model suits best
- Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker with Window and Legs (Masterbuilt) — Best overall: Large-capacity digital electric smoker with moisture and smoke control features; good for families and weekend hosts. See full details and buy the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker (Best overall): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09LDPYF2M?tag=aytxx-20
- Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Cuisinart) — Best for beginners: Simple vertical footprint, removable racks, and included water/wood trays for straightforward smoking. Shop the Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Best for beginners): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CZCKTJ4?tag=aytxx-20
- Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Model 18202077) (Char-Broil) — Best budget: No-frills analog control and a large cooking area with a 1200W heating element. Check the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Best budget) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0752DN3PB?tag=aytxx-20
- Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117) (Masterbuilt) — Best alternative: Smaller Masterbuilt digital vertical smoker option for those who want digital controls in a vertical form. View the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CN38M23?tag=aytxx-20
Why trust this guide and what information is confirmed
This guide uses product details listed by each manufacturer or retailer for the four listed electric smokers. Feature callouts in this article are taken from those product descriptions and listings: temperature capability, control style (digital or analog), cooking area or footprint, and included moisture/smoke components (water bowl or trays, adjustable dampers, racks, etc.). The goal is to help you match those listed features to how you plan to use the smoker.
Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker with Window and Legs (Best overall)
Key features (from product listing)
- Reaches temperatures up to 275°F
- Includes a water bowl to retain moisture
- Adjustable air damper for smoke control
- Product marketed with a viewing window and legs (product title)
Who it’s for
- Families or backyard hosts who want a large-capacity digital electric smoker with adjustable moisture and smoke control.
- Users who appreciate a viewing window and a raised design (legs) for easier access.
Pros
- Digital control provides more predictable heat management compared with basic analog controls.
- Water bowl and adjustable air damper provide ways to manage moisture and smoke.
- Viewing window helps monitor progress without opening the door.
Cons
- Larger footprint (40-inch) requires dedicated outdoor space.
- If you prefer a vertical rack-focused layout, a vertical model may suit you better.
See full details and buy the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker (Best overall): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09LDPYF2M?tag=aytxx-20
Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Best for beginners)
Key features (from product listing)
- 548 sq. in. cooking area (vertical footprint)
- Three removable/adjustable smoking racks
- Includes water and wood trays (smoke/water trays)
Who it’s for
- First-time smokers or cooks who want a simple vertical electric smoker with a multi-rack footprint and easy-to-adjust racks.
- People who prefer a rack-style vertical layout for multi-level smoking.
Pros
- Vertical form with 548 sq. in. of cooking area allows cooking multiple items on separate racks.
- Three removable/adjustable racks simplify loading and cleaning.
- Included water and wood trays provide built-in moisture and smoke management.
Cons
- Vertical format requires vertical clearance and may not suit those who prefer horizontal layouts.
- Listing does not indicate advanced digital controls.
Shop the Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Best for beginners): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CZCKTJ4?tag=aytxx-20
Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Model 18202077) (Best budget)
Key features (from product listing)
- Approximately 544 sq. in. cooking space
- 1200 watt heating element
- Analog control style (manual dials or basic controls)
Who it’s for
- Budget-conscious buyers who want a simple, large-area smoker with basic analog controls.
- Users who prefer simplicity over digital settings and who plan to monitor temperatures manually.
Pros
- Large cooking area (~544 sq. in.) useful for batch smoking.
- 1200W heating element provides the heating power listed by the manufacturer.
- Analog control style keeps the unit straightforward and potentially more affordable.
Cons
- Analog controls mean less precise temperature management compared with digital models.
- Listing does not specify water bowl or tray in the supplied features.
Check the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Best budget) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0752DN3PB?tag=aytxx-20
Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117) (Best alternative)
Key features (from product listing)
- Digital electric vertical smoker design (digital controls & vertical form)
- Marketed as a 30-inch Masterbuilt digital electric vertical BBQ smoker
Who it’s for
- Buyers who want Masterbuilt digital controls in a more compact vertical package.
- Those who need a smaller alternative to the 40-inch model but still want digital temperature management.
Pros
- Digital controls in a vertical form factor offer simpler control in a smaller footprint.
- Good option for patios or spaces where a 40-inch smoker would be too large.
Cons
- Smaller size means less total cooking space than the 40-inch model.
- Supplied feature set does not list specific moisture or airflow hardware.
View the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CN38M23?tag=aytxx-20
Side-by-side comparison of listed features and form factors
Control type
- Masterbuilt 40-inch: digital (title and listed features include temp up to 275°F)
- Masterbuilt 30-inch MB20071117: digital (digital vertical design)
- Char-Broil 18202077: analog control style
- Cuisinart COS-330: listing indicates straightforward controls typical of vertical models (no advanced digital features listed)
Moisture and smoke control
- Masterbuilt 40-inch: includes a water bowl and adjustable air damper (listed features)
- Cuisinart COS-330: includes water and wood trays (listed features)
- Char-Broil: listing does not specify a water bowl or tray in the supplied features
- Masterbuilt 30-inch: supplied features do not list moisture components
Cooking footprint / capacity
- Cuisinart COS-330: 548 sq. in. cooking area (listed)
- Char-Broil 18202077: ~544 sq. in. cooking space (listed)
- Masterbuilt 40-inch: marketed as large-capacity (40-inch)
- Masterbuilt 30-inch: marketed as 30-inch vertical smoker
Physical form
- Cuisinart COS-330 and Masterbuilt 30-inch: vertical smokers with rack-style layouts
- Masterbuilt 40-inch: cabinet-style smoker with window and legs
- Char-Broil: large-area smoker (analog control)
Electric smoker buyer’s guide — what to consider
Capacity and footprint
Consider cooking area numbers when listed: Cuisinart COS-330 lists 548 sq. in., Char-Broil lists approximately 544 sq. in. Those figures indicate the amount of food you can smoke at once. The Masterbuilt 40-inch is described as large-capacity and the Masterbuilt 30-inch is a smaller 30-inch vertical option—pick based on how much you cook for guests or meal prep.
Control type: digital vs. analog
Digital models (Masterbuilt 40-inch, Masterbuilt 30-inch) typically provide more consistent set-and-forget heat control than analog styles. The Char-Broil model uses analog controls, which are simpler but generally require more hands-on monitoring.
If you want simpler temperature management with less adjustment, choose a digital electric smoker. If you prefer simplicity and potentially lower cost, an analog smoker may be fine.
Moisture and smoke control
Water bowls and water/wood trays help retain moisture and add smoke flavor. The Masterbuilt 40-inch includes a water bowl, and the Cuisinart COS-330 includes water and wood trays according to their listings. The Masterbuilt 40-inch also lists an adjustable air damper for smoke control—useful for tweaking smoke intensity and airflow.
If moisture retention is important for long cooks or larger roasts, prioritize models that include water bowls or trays.
Vertical vs. horizontal form
Vertical smokers (Cuisinart COS-330, Masterbuilt 30-inch) use stacked racks—good for multiple smaller items and saving ground space. Broader cabinet-style smokers (Masterbuilt 40-inch, Char-Broil) can provide larger internal space and sometimes different door/window/leg features. Match the form to your typical cooking style.
Ease of use and maintenance
Look for removable/adjustable racks (Cuisinart lists three removable racks) to simplify loading and cleaning. Viewing windows and raised designs (Masterbuilt 40-inch includes a viewing window and legs in the product title) can make handling and monitoring simpler.
How to use the listed features to match a smoker to your needs
- If you want low-effort, consistent temps: prioritize the Masterbuilt 40-inch or the Masterbuilt 30-inch for their digital control design.
- If you are a beginner who wants simple rack-based cooking: the Cuisinart COS-330’s 548 sq. in. footprint and three removable racks make it approachable.
- If you’re on a tight budget and want a large area to smoke: the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker offers ~544 sq. in. of cooking space and a 1200W heating element in an analog package.
- If you need moisture and smoke control built-in: choose Masterbuilt 40-inch for its water bowl and adjustable air damper or Cuisinart COS-330 for its included water and wood trays.
Which one should you choose? Final recommendations by user type
- Best overall for most backyard smokers: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker with Window and Legs — large-capacity, reaches temperatures up to 275°F, includes a water bowl, and has an adjustable air damper for smoke control. See full details and buy the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker (Best overall): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09LDPYF2M?tag=aytxx-20
- Best for beginners: Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker — 548 sq. in. cooking area, three removable/adjustable racks, and included water and wood trays make it approachable. Shop the Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Best for beginners): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CZCKTJ4?tag=aytxx-20
- Best budget: Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Model 18202077) — approximately 544 sq. in. of cooking space with a 1200W heating element and analog controls for simplicity. Check the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Best budget) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0752DN3PB?tag=aytxx-20
- Best alternative (compact digital vertical): Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117) — digital vertical design for smaller spaces. View the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CN38M23?tag=aytxx-20
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the difference between a digital electric smoker and an analog electric smoker?
A: Digital models (Masterbuilt 40-inch, Masterbuilt 30-inch) provide electronic controls for temperature management; analog models (Char-Broil) use manual dials or simpler controls that often require more hands-on monitoring.
Q: Which models include ways to control moisture and smoke?
A: The Masterbuilt 40-inch includes a water bowl and an adjustable air damper per its listing; the Cuisinart COS-330 includes water and wood trays according to its listing. These features can help manage moisture and smoke during cooks.
Q: How much cooking area do the vertical models offer?
A: The Cuisinart COS-330 lists a 548 sq. in. cooking area. The Char-Broil analog model lists approximately 544 sq. in. for reference in capacity comparisons.
Q: Are these smokers suitable for beginners?
A: Yes—especially the Cuisinart COS-330, which is presented here as Best for beginners and includes removable racks and water/wood trays to simplify smoking.
Q: Do any of these models include a viewing window?
A: The Masterbuilt 40-inch product title and listing include a viewing window and legs as features.
Final Verdict
Recommendation by buyer type and compatibility:
- Choose the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker with Window and Legs if you want a large-capacity, digitally controlled smoker that lists a maximum temperature of up to 275°F, includes a water bowl for moisture, and offers an adjustable air damper for smoke control. See full details and buy the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker (Best overall): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09LDPYF2M?tag=aytxx-20
- Pick the Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker if you’re a beginner who values a 548 sq. in. vertical cooking area, three removable/adjustable racks, and included water and wood trays. Shop the Cuisinart COS-330 30″ Vertical Electric Smoker (Best for beginners): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CZCKTJ4?tag=aytxx-20
- Opt for the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Model 18202077) if you need a budget-friendly, large-area analog smoker with approximately 544 sq. in. of cooking space and a 1200 watt heating element. Check the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (Best budget) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0752DN3PB?tag=aytxx-20
- Consider the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117) as the digital vertical alternative when you want Masterbuilt’s digital controls in a smaller 30-inch vertical package. View the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Vertical BBQ Smoker (MB20071117): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CN38M23?tag=aytxx-20
Before you purchase, confirm blind type, tube size, power requirements, and smart-home compatibility on Amazon for the exact model listing you plan to buy.