AYTXX

Best Voice Assistant Displays: Echo Show and Nest Hub

As an Amazon Associate, AYTXX earns from qualifying purchases.

Introduction

Voice assistant displays are now common in homes for music, timers, video calls, smart‑home control, and quick visual info. This guide compares three smart displays—the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) bundle with Blink Mini, the All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model), and the Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation)—to help you pick the right voice assistant display based on room size, privacy needs, and which assistant ecosystem you prefer.

Quick comparison: Echo Show 8 vs Echo Show 5 vs Google Nest Hub

Why trust this guide (what this comparison covers)

This article focuses on practical buying decisions: room placement, privacy and camera needs, ecosystem tradeoffs (Alexa vs Google Assistant), and how the product information supplied here maps to common household use cases. Product descriptions and feature mentions in this article are based on the product information supplied in the text.

Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) with Blink Mini — Best overall

What it is

The Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) with Blink Mini is a mid‑size Alexa‑enabled smart display offered as an Amazon bundle that pairs the Echo Show 8 with a Blink Mini camera. The bundle is presented on the product page title, making it a convenient option for someone who wants a central home display plus an easy security camera addition.

Why it’s labeled Best overall

  • Balanced size: The Echo Show 8 sits between compact bedside displays and larger kitchen hubs, making it versatile for living rooms, shared spaces, or larger bedrooms.
  • Security add‑on: The bundle includes a Blink Mini camera (listed on the product page title), which can provide a basic monitoring option without buying a separate camera.
  • Alexa integration: As an Alexa‑enabled smart display, it fits into Alexa ecosystems for routines, smart‑home control, and voice interactions.

Pros

  • Mid‑size form factor suited to many rooms
  • Bundle includes a Blink Mini for basic camera/monitoring use
  • Alexa integration for routines and smart‑home control

Cons

  • Bundle details on advanced features beyond the product listing are not included here
  • If you prefer Google Assistant, this device uses Alexa

See full details and buy the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) bundle on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CDJHWHKM?tag=aytxx-20

All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) — Best budget

What it is

The All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) is Amazon’s compact, lower‑cost Alexa display. The product listing notes a 5.5″ display and a 2 MP camera, which can make it a good pick for bedside use, small desks, or tight counter spaces.

Why it’s labeled Best budget

  • Compact footprint: The 5.5″ display is small enough for nightstands and small surfaces where a larger display would be too bulky.
  • Built‑in camera: The 2 MP camera provides basic video‑calling and camera features without needing a separate accessory.
  • Alexa integration: As an Alexa‑enabled smart display, it works with Alexa routines and skills.

Pros

  • Small and affordable form factor
  • 5.5″ display fits tight spaces
  • 2 MP camera built in for basic calls and monitoring

Cons

  • Smaller screen limits visibility from across a room
  • If you want a separate security camera or a larger display, consider the Echo Show 8 bundle

Check the All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09B2SBHQK?tag=aytxx-20

Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) — Best alternative

What it is

The Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) is Google’s compact smart display with a 7″ screen and built‑in Google Assistant for voice control and smart‑home management. It can be a good alternative for people who prefer Google’s assistant and services.

Why it’s labeled Best alternative

  • Google Assistant: If you favor Google services (Calendar, Photos, Nest ecosystem), the Nest Hub brings Google Assistant to a 7″ display for visual feedback and controls.
  • Compact, familiar design: With a 7″ screen, it sits between the Echo Show 5 and Echo Show 8 in footprint and visibility.

Pros

  • Built‑in Google Assistant for Google‑centric users
  • 7″ display balances size and surface footprint
  • Good fit for Google smart‑home environments

Cons

  • If you prefer Alexa, Nest Hub uses Google Assistant
  • The supplied product features do not list an included camera or bundled security camera

Learn more about the Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) and shop on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CLBN88HN?tag=aytxx-20

Side‑by‑side feature summary (what each device offers)

  • Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) with Blink Mini — Best overall
  • All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) — Best budget
  • Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) — Best alternative

Buyer’s guide: how to choose a voice assistant display

1. Screen size and placement

  • Small (5–6″): Best for bedside tables, desks, or narrow counters. The All‑new Echo Show 5’s 5.5″ display is a common choice for these placements.
  • Medium: A mid‑size display like the Echo Show 8 works well in living rooms, kitchens, or shared spaces where you want larger text and video without a very large footprint.
  • 7″: The Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) at 7″ sits between compact and mid‑size and balances screen real estate with a modest footprint.

2. Camera and privacy

  • Built‑in cameras: The Echo Show 5 lists a 2 MP camera, enabling video calls and basic camera features. The Echo Show 8 bundle includes a Blink Mini camera for added monitoring or security use.
  • Decide whether you want a built‑in camera, a separate camera bundle, or no camera at all. Consider physical camera covers and how you’ll manage privacy settings within the assistant’s app.

3. Ecosystem: Alexa vs Google Assistant display

  • Alexa devices (Echo Show 8 and Echo Show 5) integrate with Alexa routines and Amazon services. If you already use Alexa devices, these displays will fit more naturally.
  • Google Assistant (Google Nest Hub) is a better fit for users who depend on Google services and devices.

4. Use case

  • Bedside alarm + quick info: Echo Show 5 is compact and budget‑friendly for bedrooms.
  • Central home hub + basic security: Echo Show 8 bundle pairs a mid‑size display with a Blink Mini camera for added monitoring.
  • Google‑centric smart home: Nest Hub (2nd Gen) is the alternative for Google Assistant users.

5. Placement and room acoustics

  • Keep displays where voice pickup is reliable and screens are visible from typical sitting spots.
  • For bedrooms, dimmable displays with night‑friendly settings are helpful—check the product’s app settings after purchase.

Setup & placement tips for each device

Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) with Blink Mini

  • Placement: Living room, kitchen counter, or shared spaces where a mid‑size screen is visible from multiple angles.
  • Setup tip: Place the included Blink Mini wired camera in a location with a clear view of the area you want to monitor; consult the Blink app and the Echo app for camera‑to‑display integrations.
  • Privacy: Review camera settings in the Blink app and Echo app; consider where you place the camera for both utility and privacy.

All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model)

  • Placement: Bedside table or small desk where the 5.5″ screen is close enough to read easily.
  • Setup tip: Use Alexa routines to set alarms, morning briefings, or night modes to make the bedside Echo Show 5 more useful.
  • Privacy: The Echo Show 5 includes a 2 MP camera—use camera disable or privacy options in the Echo app if you want to limit camera use overnight.

Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation)

  • Placement: Kitchen counter, bedside, or hallway table where a 7″ screen is helpful for quick glances.
  • Setup tip: Pair with your Google account and any Google smart‑home devices for streamlined control from the display.
  • Privacy: Review microphone and assistant‑activity settings in the Google Home app to control what’s saved or sent to Google.

Which one should you choose? Final recommendations by use case

  • Best overall for mixed use and basic security: Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) with Blink Mini bundle — choose this if you want a mid‑size Alexa display and an included Blink Mini for simple camera/monitoring options.
  • Best budget and bedside pick: All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) — choose this if you want a compact, lower‑cost Alexa display with a 5.5″ screen and a 2 MP camera for bedside alarms, quick video calls, and small‑space use.
  • Best alternative for Google users: Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) — choose this if you prefer Google Assistant and Google services and want a 7″ smart display for voice control and smart‑home management.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Which display is best for privacy?

A: Privacy choices depend on camera use and app settings. The Echo Show 5 lists a 2 MP camera, and the Echo Show 8 bundle includes a Blink Mini camera. Review device and camera privacy settings in the Echo, Blink, or Google Home apps before use.

Q: Can I use these as security cameras?

A: The Echo Show 8 bundle includes a Blink Mini camera (per the product page title) which can be used for monitoring. The Echo Show 5 has a 2 MP camera for video calling and basic camera features. Check each product’s app for camera functionality.

Q: Which assistant is better for smart‑home control?

A: That depends on your ecosystem: Echo Show devices use Alexa, and the Google Nest Hub uses Google Assistant. Choose the assistant that matches your existing smart‑home devices and services.

Q: Is the Nest Hub larger than the Echo Show 5?

A: Based on the product information cited here, the Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) has a 7″ display, while the Echo Show 5 has a 5.5″ display, so the Nest Hub is larger in screen size.

Final Verdict

Recommendation by buyer type and compatibility:

  • If you want a versatile mid‑size display with an included camera option for basic home monitoring and you use Alexa, the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) with Blink Mini bundle is the recommended option. See full details and buy the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) bundle on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CDJHWHKM?tag=aytxx-20
  • If you need a compact, budget‑friendly bedside display with a built‑in 2 MP camera and Alexa, choose the All‑new Echo Show 5. Check the All‑new Echo Show 5 (newest model) on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09B2SBHQK?tag=aytxx-20
  • If you prefer Google Assistant and a 7″ display for Google‑centric control, the Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) is the best alternative. Learn more about the Google Nest Hub (2nd Generation) and shop on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CLBN88HN?tag=aytxx-20

Before purchasing, confirm model features, power requirements, and smart‑home compatibility on Amazon.

Related Buying Guides